Title: Under the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith
Author: Jon Krakauer
Publisher: Anchor Books
Publication Year: 2003
Rating: A+
Once again, I was moved and entranced by Jon Krakauer’s storytelling. In his 2003 bestseller Under the Banner of Heaven, Krakauer explores the brutal murder of a Mormon woman and her daughter as well as an historical account of Mormonism and the development of Mormon fundamentalism.
On July 24, 1984, Brenda and Erica Lafferty were stabbed to death by their family members, who say they were instructed by God to kill their brother’s wife and fifteen-month-old daughter. Through discussions with Dan Lafferty – one of the killers – police records, and other personal accounts, Krakauer displays the lives of the Lafferty family leading up to the horrific incident. Not only does he describe their family life, but also the religious environment that fueled the fundamentalism that eventually developed among the six Lafferty brothers.
Concurrently, Krakauer dissects the history of Mormonism. This is where some of the most fascinating explorations occur. Much of the book’s focus concentrates on polygamy. Although polygamy has been outlawed by the U.S. government and denounced by the LDS (Latter-Day Saints), thousands of fundamentalists in this country still practice polygamy. There are also “polyg” sects in Mexico and Canada practicing – and spreading – their fundamentalist beliefs.
Although common opinion towards polygamy is based on the basic idea that “marriage is defined by the union of a man and a woman,” Krakauer gives a cornucopia of other reasons why individuals might find this practice abhorrent. For instance, in many cases the women have no say in who they marry. The “prophet” often decides who marries whom. In other cases, girls as young as 13 are married off. Sometimes, fathers will choose to marry their own daughters. When those daughters miscarry or give birth to mentally and physically disabled babies, the community assumes it is because of the mothers’ sins – not incest.
According to Under the Banner of Heaven, founder Joseph Smith established the doctrine of polygamy after he became interested in another woman, who wasn’t his wife. The verbiage in The Doctrine & Covenants mentions Emma Smith specifically by name because she was so distraught over Smith’s new “revelation,” which would entitle him to take other wives. Smith’s inability to keep his penis in his pants led to many, many years of oppression and incest among young women.
Another covenant that has been one of the foundations of the Mormon Church – and the cause of much detriment to the church itself – has been that each person has a direct connection with God. Anyone can have a “revelation.” It is this belief that has created so many breaches from the Church of Latter-Day Saints and has fueled Mormon Fundamentalism. It is also one of the reasons Brenda and Erica Lafferty were murdered.
Mormon’s, like many other religions, believe that some day they will inherit the earth. They do not believe in bi-racial marriages. To them, like other Christians, homosexuality is a sin. For some reason, in an era that has worked for so long towards equality, the Mormon religion has frozen millions of people in time – almost moving backwards, in a sense. According to Krakauer, Mormonism is the fastest-growing religion in the world. There are more Mormons now than there are Jews. Soon, they will become a force in this country equal to their evangelical brethren within our government. A force to be reckoned with.
One final thought: I love that in this country we have the right to believe whatever our heart’s desire. I am fascinated by the ability of Mormons to cultivate and grow this religion that was formed less than 200 years ago. But I am astounded and disgusted by the treatment of women in the fundamentalist sects. I find their racial biases atrocious. And I am even more disgusted by Americans who can point and judge other cultures, specifically Muslims, when the oppression of women and racial hatred is still alive and well in our very own country. Who the hell are we to judge?